10 Best Charcoal Pencils 2025 in the United States

The Faber-Castel 24 Piece Pitt Charcoal Set is a comprehensive collection designed for artists who enjoy working with charcoal. This set offers a variety of natural and compressed charcoal pencils and sticks in different degrees of hardness (soft, medium, and hard), which is excellent for creating a range of textures and shades in your artwork. The inclusion of a kneadable eraser and blending stump adds to the set's versatility, allowing for detailed drawing and smooth blending of charcoal marks.

Housed in a sturdy metal case, this set is both portable and durable, ensuring that your tools are well-protected and organized. The high-quality materials used in Faber-Castel products are evident in this set, providing a professional-grade experience for both beginners and experienced artists. The set might be overwhelming for complete novices due to the variety of tools included. Additionally, the medium and hard charcoal sticks might be a bit brittle, which could pose a challenge during use.

Despite these minor drawbacks, the Faber-Castel 24 Piece Pitt Charcoal Set is a valuable investment for those serious about their charcoal art.

The General's Charcoal Pencil Bundle offers a nice variety of hardness levels—2B Medium, 4B Soft, and 6B Extra Soft—covering a good range for shading and detail work. These pencils use high-quality, oil-free charcoal with an organic black formula that produces smooth, rich, and intense blacks, which is great for creating vivid drawings and blending with other media like chalk.

The cedar wood casing is easy to sharpen, allowing for precise lines and clean application, which helps keep your work neat. Because the charcoal is wrapped in wood like a regular pencil, it’s less messy than traditional charcoal sticks, making it a practical choice for classes or studio work. The set comes with 36 pencils in total, giving plenty of supply for practice or projects.

One downside is that the brand is listed as Generic, which might concern those looking for a well-known name. Also, while these pencils are praised for smoothness and blendability, charcoal as a medium can be tricky to erase perfectly, so some care is still needed during use. This bundle is a solid pick for beginners and hobbyists wanting reliable, versatile charcoal pencils without breaking the bank.

The MARKART Professional Charcoal Pencils Drawing Set offers a comprehensive solution for artists seeking versatile drawing tools. This set includes ten charcoal pencils with a variety of hardness levels: five soft, three medium, and two hard. This range allows for detailed work as well as broader strokes, making it suitable for sketching, shading, and blending.

The non-toxic, highly pigmented charcoal ensures smooth application and layering without cracking, and the pencils are designed to be break-resistant and easy to sharpen and erase, which is a great advantage for maintaining consistency in your artwork. The pencil casing is made of wood, providing a traditional feel and a contoured grip for comfortable handling.

One potential drawback is that the twist closure may not be as secure as other types, which could lead to accidental damage or loss of the pencil tips. Despite this, the set stands out for its quality and affordability, making it an excellent choice for both students and experienced artists. The brand MARKART holds a strong reputation, assuring users of the product's reliability. This set is a practical and thoughtful gift for any art enthusiast, suitable for classroom settings, portraits, still life drawings, and more.